Consignment

Do you have cards you’re looking to sell? Let Papaya maximize your earnings! Fill out the consignment request form and get started today. Please provide your email address and/or Instagram handle so we can reach out and get all the details.

Please note: We have a 50 card submission minimum. Pure base cards are not accepted.

How much will it cost?

There is a flat $7 administrative fee, which covers the review and inspection of your cards through our quality assurances process. We will carefully examine your cards to determine whether they meet our resale standards and initiate the comp process based on current market values.

A $0.30 fee will be applied to each mailing package to cover the cost of packaging materials.

How much do I get back?

You will receive 80% of the total earnings payout after Whatnot’s fees have been deducted. Administrative and packaging fees will be applied against this 80%. Payments will be issued electronically within 48 hours after the funds become available.

How do I ship my cards?

  1. Organize Your Cards

    • Group cards by driver or team to ensure a smooth inspection process.

  2. Protect Your Cards

    • Place cards in penny sleeves and secure them in top loaders or One Touches where appropriate. (Top loaders should be free of stickers and sticker residue)

  3. Package Securely

    • Ship cards in sturdy boxes and use packing material to minimize movement during transit.

    • Bubbly mailers are acceptable when paired with Ding Defends and wrapped tightly.

  4. Liability Notice

    • Papaya Pulls LLC is not liable for any damage that occurs during shipping, especially if cards are not packaged according to these guidelines.

    • Package Recording

      • All packages received by Papaya Pulls will be recorded during the opening process for record-keeping and quality assurance purposes.

Ready to turn your collection into wins?

Papaya Pledge

Upon receipt of your cards, Papaya Pulls will review and inspect them through our rigorous quality assurance process. This evaluation determines whether your cards meet our standards for resale and initiates the comp process based on current market conditions.

Cards that do not meet our quality requirements will be returned with an explanation of the issues identified. Additionally, cards with low expected resale value may also be returned to you or bundled with other cards to help maximize value potential.

Please note that how all cards presented in Papaya Pulls Consignment shows are the sole discretion of Papaya Pulls, LLC.

We will do everything in our power to get you the best bang for your buck, however if we fail to sell any of your cards within 45 days, we will refund you a pro-rated amount of the administrative fee and return your unsold cards at no cost to you.